What is Utrecht? Utrecht is just another Dutch city, a generic Dutch place if you will. Not really important, not really interesting and not really pretty. Lots of bicycles, rain and Dutch food. Holland in its most common form. So what is special about this not so special place? Utrecht currently leads one of the most complex projects I have come across, and it does so rather successfully.
At the foundation of this urban program called CU 2030 (the target year of the program, which has a bilingual website and a Facebook page) stands the central train station, which is also the largest train station in The Netherlands (due to Utrecht’s location). The train station consists of 14 platforms and almost 300,000 passengers pass through it every day. As part of the program, the station is being expanded to 19 platforms and on top of it dozens of construction and transportion projects are taking place all around. Here is what they say (I’ve highlighted the section that deals with the program partners):
Utrecht is building a new Station Area. This was much needed; ever since the Hoog Catharijne shopping mall was built in the 70s there had been overdue maintenance, neglect, a growing number of passengers, a growing city and the desire to get water back in the old canal. With the contruction of a new and renenewed area all these things are tacled at once.
The historic inner city and the Station Area were two seperated parts of Utrecht; these parts will be connected again to form one coherent centre. Liveliness and safety will be improved. There will be space for culture, leisure, the area will be better accessible and last but not least: water will flow once again in the canal that was filled in during the 70’s.
We’re building a future that’s sustainable: low emission buildings, plenty of pleasant space for bikes, public transport and pedestrians, and solar cells on top of the platforms.The building of the Utrecht Station Area is a close co-operation between the City of Utrecht, Corio (owner of Hoog Catharijne mall), Dutch Rail, ProRail and the Jaarbeurs (tradefair).
You can notice that this complex program involves five major partners – the municipality, the mall that is conencted to the train station and goes by the name Hoog Catharijne (we’ll get to it shortly), both of the Dutch rail companies and the fair grounds. There is no single boss that dictates everything for everyone. Like in many other places, The Dutch built many bad malls in the 1970s, and one of them was placed on Utrecht’s central train station. In fact, to exit from the station to the city center, one must go through the mall (also at night when all the shops are closed). The mall itself has an incoherent internal structure, which became pretty unsafe over the years until they had to shut down the upper floor entirely. As part of the train station upgrade the internal strcuture of the mall is modified so as to make a cleaner and more navigable space eventually. Before we delve further, here is a fantastic clip that explains almost everything:
The Dutch work on a grand scale. This is not a transportation plan nor a construction plan. This is solid urban planning that goes beyond just construction and transportation and includes also contact with the various stakeholders (including the residents), financing and execution. An important aspect is the day to day project management itself. The entire area of the train station lies in a complete disarray, yet the station and its shops are open for business, the mall works and accessibility for bikes, pedestrians and public transit is provided all throughout the project (even though it’s a little bit messy for Holland). The program has an information center open to public, which also provides guided group tours. Yep, the guys from Utrecht city hall do not hide beyond blank walls like is common in other countries.
The new bike parking strcuture is used for seating and relaxing in front of the new square outside of the train station. The 2015 Tour de France will start here.
The clip shown above was uploaded to the web last March. I visited the Utrecht during the month of July and it appeared to be going as planned. The new concert hall (Tivoli Vredenburg) next to station was already open. The luxurious bike parking strcture, including over 4,700 spaces is in operation, and serves as a convenient platform for relaxing. Overall, more than 30,000 bike parking spaces are planned to built around the station area (and it will not be enough). The new city hall is just about ready. You can see the other projects around the station, including daylighting of a canal that was covered during the 1970s (when even the Dutch thought that the city needs as much asphalt as possible).
Not a dull moment. The new concert hall in the background.
This post demands further discussion on the lessons that can be learned from this urban program. In the meantime, you can keep calm and know that there are public organizations that plan, manage and execute big and complex urban projects. And they do it while sticking to schedule, holding a public discussion and in the right place.
For your convenience, here is a map of Utrecht and its central train station (which is located on the western edge of the old city):
Pingback: Stations to Nowhere | Yet Another Urban Blog
I disagree with your characterization of Utrecht as “not really important, not really interesting and not really pretty” and I fear many Utrechters might take offence in these words. Even from a purely transportation perspective Utrecht is hugely important (and interesting) as the biggest rail and road hub in The Netherlands.
I agree that I may be too harsh on Utrecht, even thought it sure is a very nice place. But, from a tourist point of view when you compare ot to the bigness of Amsterdam, the beauty of Delft or the weirdness of Rotterdam, you get a pretty regular place, as far as you can call anything in The Netherlands regular.
I’m not sure you can call any place regular. I also don’t know whether you’ve been to Utrecht, but it has an ancient city centre with 2000 years of rich history, uniquely styled canals, Rietveld Schröderhuis – a UNESCO listed property, absolutely flourishing student life and is the 4th largest city in The Netherlands. So yes, it is “just another city”, but “Lots of bicycles, rain and horrible food” is a degenerative stereotype and I honestly expected more from a PhD candidate at the Department of Geography and Human Environment.
Yes. I have been there for a conference. I have taken the photos in this post. May be a bit too harsh in the terms I used and I appreciate your feedback (I made it a bit less harsh). We had a good time in Utrecht, but we sure did get a lot of rain and the Dutch croquettes are not real food.
Well yes, there is a case for Dutch cuisine being the most confliciting word combination ever, but the situation has rapidly improved in recent years. Perhaps it is important to distinguish snack from “real food” – English food is not limited to fish’n’chips just as French food is not only baguete and cheese.
Looking forward to read more of your articles, perhaps a comment about the reconstruction of Christchurch?
Thanks. I haven’t been to Christchruch and I plan to have a few more articles on Israeli planning issues before returning to European issues. I plan to write about a similar project in Stuttgart that go derailed because the Germans are not as good in urban planning as the Dutch.
Pingback: Stuttgart 21 – A Delayed Discussion | Yet Another Urban Blog